World Affairs

Israel is DOOMED-Prof John Mearsheimer

By: John Mearsheimer   July 29, 2025
https://img.youtube.com/vi/1Zel0FY3dbE/maxresdefault.jpghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Zel0FY3dbE

In the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, there are approximately 7.3 million Jews and 7.3 million Palestinians. This demographic parity isn't just a statistic - it's a time bomb.

As the Israeli government continues to pursue extreme right-wing policies, forcibly displacing Palestinians and tightening its grip over Gaza and the West Bank, the question isn't just about morality anymore. It's about sustainability.

What happens when a state that relies on military domination begins to lose the faith of its own population?

A False Sense of Security

Even if Israel were to succeed in expelling all Palestinians - a goal that some in power seem to flirt with - the problem wouldn't end there. The greater question becomes: Will Israeli Jews continue to feel safe enough to stay? Already, many are quietly leaving. Wars, missile threats, and the looming specter of a nuclear Iran have spooked the population. How many will remain when the next war breaks out? Or the one after that?

As one observer noted, Israel today is the size of a postage stamp, bordered by enemies it keeps creating through its policies. If Iran were to gain nuclear capabilities - while diplomatic relations remain toxic - would anyone truly feel safe living in Tel Aviv?

Netanyahu's Gamble

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu continues to place his bet on the West - particularly the United States - blindly backing Israel's actions. But this strategy is short-sighted. The atrocities in Gaza, the mass starvation, the indiscriminate bombings - these aren't isolated military operations. They are being broadcast live to the world, and the world is watching in horror.

Western leaders may stay silent, but civil societies are not. Thousands of Holocaust survivors, their children, and human rights organizations have labeled Israel's current assault on Gaza as a genocide. And unlike the past, this label is beginning to stick.

Daniel Levy, a former Israeli negotiator, and Omar Bartov, an Israeli-born Holocaust historian, are among the growing number of voices daring to say what once was unthinkable: Israel's actions mirror the very atrocities it claims to stand against.

When Genocide Becomes a Mirror

Israel has long wielded the memory of the Holocaust as both shield and sword - using it to justify its own existence while silencing critics who draw parallels. But that control is slipping. As Palestinian suffering reaches unspeakable levels, comparisons to Nazi-era brutality are no longer taboo - they are being made by Jews, scholars, and Holocaust survivors themselves.

When Israel dares the world to compare, it shouldn't be shocked when the world finally does.

The Lobby and the Cracks in Liberal America

The pro-Israel lobby in the United States - once discreet and strategic - is now out in the open, playing "smashmouth politics." It's working overtime to suppress speech, blacklist dissenters, and silence criticism. But in doing so, it is sowing the seeds of backlash. American society, which prides itself on free speech and liberal values, is beginning to resist.

The lobby's tactics are not only eroding support among progressives but are also creating an unsustainable political environment for Jewish Americans who don't support Israel's policies. The contradictions are becoming too large to ignore.

Where Does This End?

Let's imagine the "best case scenario": a ceasefire, supply trucks allowed into Gaza, and the world breathes a momentary sigh of relief. Even then - Gaza is still rubble. Over two million people are displaced, traumatized, and destitute. There is no future for them under the current status quo. And Netanyahu knows it.

But instead of seeking peace, Israel doubles down. Its supporters chant for more force, more control, more walls. But no wall - no matter how high - can contain the demographic, political, and moral reckoning that is coming.

The Illusion of the Iron Wall

This ideology, rooted in Vladimir Jabotinsky's "Iron Wall" doctrine - that only unrelenting force can subdue the native population - has run its course. It may have worked for a while. But history teaches us that no colonial project can indefinitely suppress an indigenous people without breaking under the weight of its own contradictions.

Israel is in real trouble. Not because of external enemies, but because its internal fractures - moral, political, and demographic - are now impossible to ignore. A nation cannot remain both Jewish and democratic while ruling over millions who have no vote, no state, and no rights.

The future won't be decided by how many bombs Israel drops or how many lobbyists it sends to Washington. The future will be decided by how long it can ignore the reality it has created - and how long the world will let it get away with it.

Author: John Mearsheimer   July 29, 2025
Author: Home