Expert Warnings About Cartoons Unheeded
Recent revelations show that the Danish Jyllands Posten newspaper consulted experts before publishing the caricatures that caused conflict between Denmark and the Islamic world.
Professor Tim Jensen, a prominent Danish theologian, said the caricatures should not be published, warning the newspaper "It will offend Muslims and only cause pointless provocation." A lecturer at South Denmark University, Mr. Jensen summarized his answer to a reporter from Zaman regarding the Jyllands Posten newspaper: "Surely, Denmark has freedom of press, but pictures of the Prophet Mohammed have never existed throughout history. Any picture or caricature to be published will offend Muslims deeply. It would be provocation in a climate where Islam and Muslims are already in the limelight. It's like pouring gas on the fire."
Another point Professor Jensen, a leading expert on religious history and the author of 'Religion Guide' to Islam, Christianity, and Judaism, noted is the depiction of the Prophet Mohammed as a terrorist. "In a climate where Islam is associated with terrorism, depicting the Prophet Mohammed with a bomb on his head is both offensive and insulting" said Jensen, underlining the involved caricatures go beyond normal caricatures or pictures. Jensen added he requested the newspaper evaluate thoroughly its responsibilities and avoid any publications that would rupture up Denmark's relationship with Muslims.
Leading ecclesiastics of Denmark called for moderation of tensions. Copenhagen Bishop Erik Norman Svendsen condemned both the burning of a Danish flag and insulting the Prophet Mohammed via caricatures. Svendsen, calling on Danish citizens to take a cool look, said, "We should not cut dialogue with Muslims." The Viborg Bishop said, "It is difficult for certain people among Danish citizens who do not pay enough attention to religion to realize how far they go when talking about Islam and Muslims." Loland Faster Bishop Steen Skovsgaard said the wound caused by the caricatures will take long time to heal, adding, the dialogue should go on.
Related Suggestions
Over all I enjoy your sensible comments and wish you well.
Peace!
Why are so many Muslims so extremely violent. Thousands of them Kill people in the name of Allah. The people that do that are extremely religous Muslims, so they must get these killing instructions from their leaders, who must get it from the Quoran. Sure, there are murderous westerners who do violent things to inoccent people. But you never hear of a Christian blowing up innocent people and then hear other Christians say praise be to Jesus. After hearing new reports showing how many so people in the Muslim countries thought that blowing up the towers in New York was great, I came to believe that Islam is our enemy. Violence seems to be what so many Muslims believe in
You and your parients and your grnad parients are in a deep lost.
Try to know what ISLAM is? And the wholy prophet (SAWS)
Allah (GOD) forgive the people that did this to your beloved prophet MOHAMMAD (SAWS) they no not what they are doing.
When Europe got destroyed after second world war, Muslims were good for buiding your lives and now they are worth shit. Instead of insulting muslims maybe you should thank them.
I believe that the Muslims should not take this insult in such a manner as they have since if you take time to read a bit about the religion, even the Prophet Muhammad (Pbuh) him self was insulted truly and vigorously by oppressors in his time and he stayed quite ignoring their manners and praying for them. He used to pray for his enemies and that is the quality of the messengers of God. Therefore, when someone cursed at the Prophet (Pbuh) or hurt the Propet (Pbuh), he would straighten out his companions to excercise patience and forgiveness, and if the Muslims practiced these aspects, the whole aspect of this insulting cartoon could have backfired...however Muslims fail to read and learn their religion properly, thus, resulting themeselves in the dilemma they are in now.
What if Khomeini had not issued any fatwa against him? Issue of 'insult' to Islam would never have arisen.
Now some crazy dane publishes some cartoons. If muslims had not paid any attention to it, the issue of 'insult' to Prophet and Islam would never have arisen.
Now plenty of kooks are going to get all kinds of anti-islamic ideas, and are going to have a field day in satirizing and carricaturing Islam, Prophet and muslims. You thought the crazy dane was nasty; wait what you will see from others over the next few years. Internet is a media which is uncontrollable. Just ask the UK government; they asked Craig Murray not to publish the 'secret' documents; he did it any how; and now UK government finds itself defending 'torture'.
One must learn to ignore things if one wants to have any semblance of peace of mind, otherwise you are going to go crazy (and lot of people would love to incite muslims to go crazy, so that they can implement anti-islamic agends).
Come on fellows, get hold of yourself; like it or not, the world has changed. Nobody knows what can be and will be offensive to anybody and everybody; if we worried about not offending anybody, we will never be able to say anything at all.
In Europe, Christ has been carricatured as a Homosexual, and nobody paid any attention to it.
If muslims took these cartoons in stride, the issue would have died right away. Now, these cartoons are available to everybody in the world on the internet and people will be making new ones and circulating them widely on the internet.
21:107 We sent thee not, but as a Mercy for all creatures.
9:33 It is He Who hath sent His Messenger with guidance and the Religion of Truth, to proclaim it over all religion, even though the Pagans may detest (it).
48:28 It is He Who has sent His Messenger with Guidance and the Religion of Truth, to proclaim it over all religion: and enough is Allah for a Witness.
61:9 It is He Who has sent His Messenger with Guidance and the Religion of Truth, that he may proclaim it over all religion, even though the Pagans may detest (it).
DEAR LANCE BOYLE..U SAY 'MERE CARTOONS'!!!ITS NOT A MERE CARTOON..ITS LIFE N FAITH OF MUSLIMS. JUST THINK IF IT WERE ABT YOUR RELIGION U WUD SAY IT A 'MERE CARTOON'? NO U WONT THEN U'LL E AGAINST IT.THATS MEANS IF IT WAS TO YOU U FEEL BAD N WEN ITIS DONE TO OTHERS U HAVE NO PRBLEM..IS THIS YOUR CHARACTER? JUST ANSWER ME IF IT WERE SOMETHING INSULTING THE POPE OR BISHOPS? N JUST THINK WHY ISLAM IS THE FASTEST GROWING RELIGION...YOU CAN NEVER PREDICT WHETHER YOU'LL ACCEPT ISLAM ONCE OR NOT..LIFE N HUMAN MID ARE BEYOND PREDICTABE..THEN WE'LL SEE WAT U FEEL.
MR.CONCERNED..U POINTED OUT SOME INCIDENTS THAT DIDNT RAISE OUTRAGE AMONG MUSLIMS..HAE U EVR RIED TO LEARN THE REASONS BEHIND IT? THIS IS NOT ABOUT COMMON MUSLIMS..THIS IS ABOUT THE PERSON MOST LOVABLE N LOVED BY THE MIUSLIM GOD THE ALLAH ALMIGHTY. NO ORDINARY MUSLIM IS EQUALL TO ANY PROPHET...ABRAHAM,MOSES, JESUS,OR MOHAMMED(PBU THEM).SO NEVER COMPARE A PERSON TO PROPHET. INSULTING A PROPHET,A GREAT PIOUS PERSONALITY THE WORLD HAVE EVER SEEN IS BEYOND ANY LIMIT. HE WAS A PERSON WHO PRAYED FOR THE WELL BEING OF THE PEOPLE WHO TORTURED N INSULTED HIM..CAN U SHOW SUCH A PERSON AMONG UR SELVES?
THIS IS NOT A MERE CARTOON BUT AN INTENDED ATTACK ON MUSLIM FAITH N FEELINGS.FROM THE ARTICLE ITS CLEAR THAT THERE NEWSPAPERS HAVE BEEN WARNED BY SOME GREAT PERSONS(REMEMBER THEY R FROM UR RELIGION) BEFORE THESE THINGS WERE PUBLISHED..SO IT IS DONE INTENTIONALLY.
SO THINK TWICE BEFORE DISAGREEING ANYTHING. JUST SAYWAT WUD U DO IF THIS WERE ABT UR RELIGION? I'LL TELL U. THEN U WILL BE AGAINST THE PUBLISHERS.AS LONG AS ITS NOT ABT UR RELIGION,FAITH N FEELINGS U PEOPLE WONT HAVE ANY PROBLEM..N THATS WAT REALLY CALLED AS HIPOCRACY!!! MAY ALLAH THE ALMIGHTY FORGIVE U N UR PEOPLE WHO RAISE THEIR VOICE AGAINST 'HIS' PROPHET AND RELIGION AND SAVE U ALL FROM HIS FURY WHICH IS BEYOND UR IMAGINATION POWER...
Peace!
The way out of the dilemma? Simple.The Danish government should apologize that such an embarrassing act escaped their "security watch" and put the newspaper to officially retract and apologize for their carelessness and insensitivity. Let's not continue to confuse the Muslims with the terrorists!
My heart is misgiving me on your comment.
Your vile propanada underscores the war you low life morons are waging against the religion of 1 billion people, with misinformation, 1/2 truths etc....
Where is the outrage when israelis whoot palestinians in the head? when Dubya murders 200,000 iraqis? Spread DU which kills people long term?
Christians:
1. Massacred millions of Japanese by dropping Atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki
2. Massacred 800,000 Vietnamese by nepalm bombs, poisioning their villages, burning, raping, looting and plundering helpless villagers just because they could
3. Massacred almost 60% of the Jewish race in Germany. Gassed millions. Burned their remains in giant human born fires. Used their skins as canvas to paint pictures and make trinkets.
3. Massacred millions of Muslims in the baltic states under the Russia's Christian rulers.
4. Massacred and dispossessed 450,000 Chechnyan Muslims.
5. Christian Serbs and Croats massacred 1.5 million Muslim men, women and children in Bosnia and Albania. Women were raped. A 2 year old boy was beheaded in front of his parents. Girls as young as 4 were raped and murdered. Muslims were forced to dig their own graves and shot. In shallow graves revealed mases of Muslim men, women and children burned to death. Read this Einstein: http://www.mediaclub.cg.yu/eng/articles/2000/april/05.htm
6. Christian Hutus cut to pieces 820,000 Christian and Muslim Tutsis, egged on by Christian priests and nuns. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4615171
7. Christian Inquisition of Muslims and Jews. Hundreds of thousands tortured, chopped up or forced to convert.
The List goes on and on. Interesting hw the Jews have learnt well from teh Christians and now together they aim to rob, kill, loot and essentially destroy Muslims and Islam. I thought after the Holocaust you Christians would feel some shame, but you Christians repeated your filthy slaughter yet again in Bosnia and Albania.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/4670379.stm
The world does have reason to fear you lunatics. Especially American Christians who sow hatred and use their special weapons of mass slaughter on weaker nations. God is watching. God is all pow
Muslims cut off the heads of three teenaged girls on their way to school in Indonesia. A Christian school. No Muslim outrage.
Muslims murder teachers trying to teach Muslim children in Iraq. No Muslim outrage.
Muslims slaughter hundreds of children and teachers in Beslan, Russia. Muslims shoot children in the back. No Muslim outrage.
A stupid cartoon and muslims are ready to kidnap and murder innocent people. There are riots in the streets. You are condemning an entire nation over the actions of ONE MAN, yet muslims are offended when they are targeted because of the actions of a few fanatics.
The hypocracy is disgusting to the entire world.
Go update your knowledge.
This is a fundamental difference between Islam and Christianity. In the Islamic world, it seems that you seek temporal justice (i.e, the calls by some Islamic clerics to behead those who have done this). Christ teaches forgiveness and that ultimate justice comes from God, not from us. In fact, it is sinful for us to seek revenge.
Though we are supposed to stand up for the persecuted, help the victims of tyrants, intervene when someone is being murdered--being insulted personally, or hearing someone insult God does not give us cause to kill or injure that offending person. God can stand up for himself. Our job is to represent His love in this world, not His vengeance. That day will come and is reserved for Him alone.
Jesus said "But I tell you who hear me: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you."
Even if you don't believe that Jesus is God, Muslims say that they believe in the words of Jesus. I pray that Muslims will listen to the words of Christ and forgive their enemies, not seek to behead them. If you believe in God, trust in God, not your own swords.
by the way Allah will take revange ,what about us {muslim} sons of shatan is playing with the holy name prophet we his followers with his grace we got right path, we still living ,shame on us!!!
What angers me is the way the media is handling this. They are addressing the issue as simply being the cartoons of the prophet (pbuh), and ignoring the most important part. If it was just cartoon depictions of the prophet(pbuh), I don't think you'd get outrage were seeing. The really issue is the CONTENT of the cartoons, which is very insulting and disrespectful.
If people don't address the content of the cartoons, than people won't see the problem with a few drawings.
They have tried to justify these cartoons by using the "free speech" arguement. Free speech is not an excuse to be insulting and disrespectful.
Freedom of thought seems to be absent from Islamic
teachings. Maybe it is true that there are more radical
fanatics than Muslims care to admit. Burying one's head
in the sand and saying Islam teaches peace seems to
always be the standard. But evidenced by the reaction
to mere cartoons, Violence is the Muslim's first reaction.
A relegion is defined not by it's teachings, but how it is
practiced.
yes violence is not answer to this butI don't mind peaceful protest in shape of european product ban and recalling ambassdors that will continue to remind their hyprocrisy. All religion should be protected and respected. No one is special.
Again respect is the only thing that can save the moment. My protest to all disfigurements of any religion and all should be respected.
Every action has reaction so damage is done so enjoy the heat that it is causing if you like it or not.
It is not "just a cartoon", the holy prophet (PBUH)is the central figure in the religion of Islam and to depict him in an insulting way is more than a personal offence.The Western media has no idea about the person.
I, however, do not believe in a violent response. I believe in creating a modern muslim state and society where all muslims and non-muslims would live their lives following the social model of islam, free of such hatred, free of the mindless freedoms of ailing western societies.An "alternative" reality to the current religion of "supreme human will and pleasure." I believe once we get there,all the islamic nations together,a true muslim Ummah without current boundries,in the true spirit of Islam, we will not be plundered, pushed, bombed, ridiculed, humiliated. No one will ridicule Mohammed or Jesus or Moses.
All we need is faith in Allah and look to Mecca rather than Washington/London/Moscow.
That my brothers and sisters should be the Muslim response-not killing/bombing/burning.
So far I am 1. Anyone else shares that dream?
I beleive there are experts in every publishing house; the danish newspaper staff definately know before publishing that muslims are sensitive to this but they deliberately published it. It seems somone is saying to us "We know you love your prophet more then your life; we know your values; but we are going to joke them; do whatever the hell you can do"
This western attitute makes the blood boil; and there is a very strong thinking in muslim youths that west is never going to realize it until "It happen to them". It is only then we see "sucide bombers" who blow up and themselves to make it happen to them.
How long and how much it takes for them to realize it?
Haroon Zakariya
http://insightislam.blogspot.com
bashar saleh
Our Prophet sws is, up until this day, an honourable and well loved man. He did for this world what no other has been able to. Unfortunately, Muslims do not follow his example of patience and kindness in the face of hypocrasy and ridicule. Instead of warring and bringing more violence we should use our intelligence and the example of graciousness we were shown by the Prophet sws to bring a better understanding of Islam to the world. Think about it...If the Prophet sws had threatened war and been violent towards all those who ridiculed him, would Islam be what it is today??
Ya Allah, help the muslims and guide us to the way of your beloved...Aameen
Ma'Salaam
Allah is Great, Muhammad Mustafa S.A.W. is always respected. If Allah does not punish those who are included in printing, it means that Allah will punish them with greater and never ending punishments in the next world. Allah is Great for all of us, Muhammad Mustafa S.A.W. is worth wishing "Peace and blessings be upon Him".
Firstly, I'd like to thank the wise bishops who were mentioned in the article and who were consulted by the newspaper and who have warned the paper's staff before publishing those caricatures.
Secondly, i want all those living on this planet to live in peace and harmony, respect each other because we didn't come to this world to hate each other for 'God is love' or to destroy but to build and establish bridges of friendship and respect between souls and hearts of the others.
Thirdly,we should know that freedom is a big responsibility. We are free unless we harm others.I wonder why there is a law that bans smoking in public places because smoking will harm the others and at the same time the same law not only gives those journalists the right to harm our feeligs, insult the one who brought humanity out of the darkness of worshiping idols and worshipping man-created false gods to worshipping The Creator of everything,but also protects them. Those who insulted the one who brought people out from a society where the strong exploited and enslaved the weak to a society where the strong helps and gives a hand to the weak and sustains the poor and the orphans, from a spciety full of crimes, vice and aggression into a society full of virtue and peace, the one who was illiterate but kept the Quran by heart and taught,explained it to his companions.
Finally, what have the Danes got out of all that? You should know the limits of freedom. Should you kill me because you don't like me because you are free? Why don't we live and let others live beside us? Why don't we do as we'd like to be done by? This is the true freedom and the responsibility of the freedom we would like you to understand and live to. We should not be like Orwell's sheep in Animal Farm and be affected of that cunning wave of accusing Islam and Muslims of terrorism which is a mere reaction to the double standards.Know