temporary marriage/mut`a

Sign*Reader, first of all, I have recognized that you rely pretty much on the news and specially the way an author may analyze them and you may make/change your belief based on them. We should keep in mind that such news and the analysis behind them could be designed intentionally to weaken the consensus in Muslims and to depart between Shia and Sunni.

Secondly, I am not saying that there are no such problems in Iran. More or less there might be. However, what is its relation with Shia belief system? I know that the majority in Iran is Shia, but how do you know if the majority of them are really practicing it in their everyday life? Your argument is similar to the argument of a non-Muslim in this forum listing some problems in one Islamic society and starts disproving Islam because of such a list. How do you reply to such argumentation?

Furthermore, a prostitute by definition is one whose job is to accept payment for sex acts. If one is doing so and thinks or claims that her work is Temporary Marriage in Shia she is absolutely wrong. She is deceiving herself and others. Even one who abuse marriage is doing Haram in Shia beleife. Fortunately, Fatah-Momin brought the evidence from Al-Kafi:

The Holy Prophet (p.b.u.h.) said: "Certainly, Allah, Almighty and Glorious, dislikes or curses any man or woman whose intention of divorce or marriage is merely tasting the pleasure of it."

Therefore, even if in Iran some people are practicing so they are not following Ahlul-Bayt and Shia 12 Imams. This is their fault but not the Ahlul-Bayt problem.

My posts are in moderation que, I do not know why,If any Shia dispute my claim,  I welcome on on one debate, and I promise not to use my language or proof from Ahley Sunnah, I will only post from Shia source in Shia own words with out any interpolation, I will establish that Shia do not believe in Quran as the uncorrupted last testament of Allah[swt]. Now back to the topic at hand here is another proof fromShia book that Mutah is fronication.

Book: "Wasael ush shia", chapter Nikah.
Author: Hurr al Amele.

Ali ibn Abe Taleeb (radi Allahu anhu) said:

"Prohet (sallalahu alayhi wa ala alihi wa salam) forbade meat of domestic donkey and mutah marriage in the day of khaybar".

Author of book tried to explain it like taqiyah, that shows us that he accepted that narration as authentic.

Salaams, all

As far as Qur'aan is concerned, there is not a single verse or command for Muta'a, which simply means having fun. The word does not even mean marriage.

Referring to Fatah-Momin's post containing a note in Urdu, Qur'aan does not even give any conditions for that.

Qur'aan speaks of Nikah and related words such as

فانكحوهن

and there is no word and no verse to show that one could have fun or a marriage for a fixed period.

4:24 does not allow Muta'a at all and there is nothing that suggests that Muta'a can be done for a certain term or period.

Salaams
BMZ

Shia can marry their Step sisters.

I am restricted to one post a day and that post is on moderation que, if moderators allow I will only post Shia source in shia words and will NOT interpolate with my input member can read and judge for themselves, IF sHIA ARE KAFIR OR NOT


Edited by Fatah-Momin - 24 May 2009 at 8:53pm