Sin

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

   In the name of God, the merciful and the compassionate
My apologies for my delay in this subject but I will not delaye no more so let address some of the responses here.
(switching font)
Patty you said in Bold:

Hi Israfil....I'll be happy to "take a crack at it"
The immunity from original sin was given to Mary by a singular exemption from a universal law through the same merits of Christ, by which other men are cleansed from sin by baptism. Mary needed the redeeming Saviour to obtain this exemption, and to be delivered from the universal necessity and debt (debitum) of being subject to original sin. The person of Mary, in consequence of her origin from Adam, should have been subject to sin, but, being the new Eve who was to be the mother of the new Adam, she was, by the eternal counsel of God and by the merits of Christ, withdrawn from the general law of original sin. Her redemption was the very masterpiece of Christ's redeeming wisdom. He is a greater redeemer who pays the debt that it may not be incurred than he who pays after it has fallen on the debtor. 

Patty although you eloquently explained this, this does not explained how Mary was without sin. According to some Catholic theologians especially Thomas Aquinas, the soul while still in the Empyrean is without sin, since it is in the presence of the Creator and when it comes to its earthly form and being formed in the womb of the mother who is of sin the child inherits it through blood I assume (or by its transition in the physical plane?).
Since Mary historically was born in the same process like we all are, how did God make her exempt from the universal law of inherited sin?
Brother David said:
Israfil, you must consider the power of the Holy Spirit to sanctify and forgive.  Mary was not born without sin, but she was sanctified and free from sin at the immaculate conception.

Her sister, Elizabeth, was similarly sanctified at merely believing the miracle in Luke 1:41
(Changing color fonts to dinstinguish my response from brother DavidC)
Brother David it appears that your answer differs from the previous where Patty states that Mary was exempt from the universal law. According to some Christians whom I've discussed with even with using Biblical verses it basically boiled down to "Mary was just born without sin, thus having the ability to conceive a sinless Christ."
My question here is seeing how Mary was born in the same process and I assume some Christians believe that the blood carries the sin of Adam and Eve and since Mary being formed from a cell, fetus and to a fully formed baby how in that time of being formed did she not inherit the sin of her father and mother and their ancestors and so on? Unless it is not explained in the Bible of course I understand there cannot be an answer here. But brother David as you have clearly mentioned that Mary was not born sinless but was sanctified through conceiving Jesus if I am right....
Angela used several opinions here using Eastern Orthodoxy:

I decided to take a crack at this one using Eastern Orthodoxy.  I went to the OCA and the OCF websites and retrieved some things that would help you understand the other side of the coin from a Mainstream Christian standpoint.  I still hold many of these beliefs.
ORIGINAL SIN
QUESTION: 

I would like to know what is the orthodox canon regarding the "original sin." The following confuse me: 

Father Michael Azkoul states that God punished man only once for the original sin by introducing death, and the original sin wasn't transferred to the next generations. 

He says (on the OCF website): "The Church does not accept the idea that the Mother of God was born with the (inherited) guilt of Adam; no one is ..." 

On the Greek Orthodox Metropolis of Toronto's page there is a totally different statement:
"Worst of all, original sin is hereditary. It did not remain only Adam andEve's." 

(Changing font to distinguish from Angela's post)
It appears that from what was stated one believes sin is inherited and the other belives that the recompensationm for sin is death of all humans thus there is no inheriting sin. Following the listed reference you baiscally state that the Holy Spirit redeemed Mary, and you acknowledge according to your reference that she had sinned but was redeemed and sanctified to prepare her body for the conception of Christ. I understand your explanation here.
My further question (which was brought up by a statement here) is since sin cannot be scientifically proven to be in the blood and/physical compartments of the human body how is sin inherited? We surely cannot say death because if only humans sinned why do animals or any living creature suffer for what a human does for that matter? Surely animales suffer death the same as we do. Also, I present the theory that isn't it possible that God could create Jesus in the womb of a sinner? Perhaps one can still be a virgin and in the case of Christian theology still have the inherited Sin?