Islam and Terrorism

MOCKBA

You wrote: "The question in your second post is not very clear." It is as clear as a bell and very simple: I will restate it. If a Christian converted to Islam in order to obtain free room and board at a madrass, would you consider that conversion valid? It is a simple yes or no question.

You also referenced Dr. Philips' stand on terrorim. He wrote: "...Islaam opposes any form of indiscriminate violence..." My question to you on this matter is also simple and clear. Do you believe the hyjackers of 9/11 committed an indiscriminate form of violence? It is yet one more simpe yes or no question.

You also wrote: "Perhaps Katzman makes you see the world in his own eyes..." I do not know who Katzman is. However, the thing he reported was also widely reported by others. Once again my question to you is simple yes or no. Do YOU believe the women of Israel are rightly the physical property of the Jihaddists opposing Israeli Imperialism. Or not?

Bismillah

Ejdavid,

I have answered you at length. The validity of one's conversion, whether it is for material gain or out of sincere faith - is for the Most High to judge. 

I refuse any comments that try to link 9/11 with Islam. Through Dr. Bilal Philips statement, I have made Islam's position on terrorism clear. Do you need more?

If you are not able to comprehend simple things, it seems you are not ready to absorb the subject on female captives and their status at the time of war from and Islamic perspective. They are not as you describe "physical properties of jihadists" but have a status above that of a common prisoners of war and can not be approached against their will.

In fact, Islam always encouraged freeing this kind of women. This kind of treatment is perhaps why throughout history many captives willingly and without force accepted Islam and later fought in line with their brother Muslims.    

Taking into account the importance of the subject of captives, I shall try to contribute a couple of useful and relevant articles for everyone's attention in a separate thread. Stay tuned.

Edited by MOCKBA

MOKBA

PS: Thanks for the clarification on the status of captives. It is much appreciated. Thanks....

.

Edited by Hanan