GUIDELINES???? what guidelines?

Assalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh

First of all I'd like to thank the moderators for their hard work etc. etc. etc.

Ok, now here's the question.

Just now another one of my threads was closed: http://www.islamicity.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=7785& ; ;PN=1&TPN=5

Moderator peacemaker said that I had gone against the guidelines, but did not point out which.

However, it seems it was Duende who reported me, as she had accused me of spamming.

So I read the guidelines and read the part disallowing spamming, it says:

12.  Spamming of any kind is not allowed. Any response to spammers will be deleted along with the spam. This includes multiple copies (2 or more) of one message in one and/or many forums. (If this behavior is spotted several times, by the same User we may remove ALL the copies of that message, including all the responses below them.) Spamming of questions or overly large posts will also not be allowed.

13. Posting several messages at random and not responding to the generated questions or dialogue following the original posts may also be considered as spamming. Answer questions posed to you and do not avoid it by changing the topic, as long as that question does not break any of the Guidelines. If you do not know the answer, simply acknowledge this, then move forward.

I did not make two or more copies of one message, I made one copy. (and the rules say you must repeat this and so even if I did I should have got a warning first)

Guideline 12 says

 Posting several messages at random and not responding to the generated questions or dialogue following the original posts may also be considered as spamming,

But of course if you read the thread I took the time to answer all relevant (and even most irrelevant) questions before posting again.

Answer questions posed to you and do not avoid it by changing the topic, as long as that question does not break any of the Guidelines

I answered the questions and did not change the topic and continued posting about Iran USA relations. And the question does not break any guidlines that I know of.

The same moderator (peacemaker) also deleted my posts on another thread: http://www.islamicity.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9776& ; ;PN=1

I had said nothing against the guidelines, I said Iran treats Jews well but they treat Sunnis badly. Which guidline does that break???

So one of my threads was closed and one of my posts was deleted. I request that the thread be re-opened and hope no moderator would repeat the same mistake simply due to recieving constant "reports" from members who are complaining not because any rules have been broken, but because they disagree with the topic.

Thank you

peacemaker wrote: "The same moderator (peacemaker) also deleted my posts on another thread:"   http://www.islamicity.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9776& ; ; ; ;PN=1 How do you know who deleted that? Please refrain from saying something without evidence.

you also closed the sawtulvswhisper thread which I had started to Prevent other threads from going off topic (since u Never delete Whisper's off topic posts on my threads)

peacemaker wrote: Anyway, let me make your job easier. I deleted that due to violation of guidelines.

Which guideline? which rule did I violate???? Why dont you mention the rule I violated in the 2 Threads you closed, especially the "USA benefits Iran" thread.

peacemaker wrote: If this continues, such posts/threads will be deleted further. Nobody will be an exception.

I guess nobody will be an exception so long as their username is Sawtul Khilafah.

Please just answer this 1 question:

Which part of the guidelines did I violate on the "USA benefits Iran" thread? Please be specific.

Abu Mujahid wrote: peacemaker wrote: "The same moderator (peacemaker) also deleted my posts on another thread:"   http://www.islamicity.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9776& ; ; ; ; ;PN=1 How do you know who deleted that? Please refrain from saying something without evidence. Anyway, let me make your job easier. I deleted that due to violation of guidelines. If this continues, such posts/threads will be deleted further. Nobody will be an exception. Peace   Peacemaker! what a name Why not explain to him what guidelines he voilated?. Your talk is very scary.  One moderator did to me same before. No explaniation ........follow guidelines. just direct orders!!! I thought you owe to him real explaniation. BTW, do you guys funded by current Saudi Regime so you adopt their way of doing business: don't ask ........istarih?!!!!!!!  follow the sheikh!!!     Abu Mujahid

Assalamu Alaikum,

Since Brother Sawtul Khilafah started this thread to seek clarification about his concerns, it would be inappropriate to meddle in this thread by you, and let the moderator(s) deal with him. It is also impolite to come in between in this manner.

You were warned couple of times in the past and it was expected that things would be better with you, insha Allah, but it appears that you tend to mock at what was done.

It is not the way believers should interact! In future, please don't interrupt in such issues:

14. The "Comments and Complaints" section is not a discussion forum where all Users may take part. Only the concerned User, with the original complaint (topic starter), and IC Moderators/Administrators should take part in conversations so that the complaint can be appropriately resolved. Besides, if a complaint is also shared by many others, dealing with it would automatically help others as well. For example: If 50 people have the same complaint, responding to the original post of User (topic starter) would obviously address all concerned Users. Moderators should be addressed respectfully and complaints should be made politely.

http://www.islamicity.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=4589& ;PN=1

Peace