Muslims: What of this theory?

AliBaba, you are REALLY reaching here. If your sole intent is to try to discredit Islam and drag it through the mud, then I suggest you move on to another site.

Anyone can come up with crazy theories. Can you discredit the Da Vinci Code? Can you discredit the theory that Jesus is buried in a sepulcher in Kashmir? Can you discredit the recently discovered Gospel of Judas? At least this ancient parchment exists. Prove it's a lie, if you can...

"the original language of the Qur�an was not was not Arabic but something closer to Aramaic. He says the copy of the Qur�an used today is a mistranscription of the original text from Muhammad�s time, which according to Islamic tradition was destroyed by the third caliph, Osman, in the seventh century. But Arabic did not turn up as a written language until 150 years after Muhammad�s death, and most learned Arabs at that time spoke a version of Aramaic."

The answer can be seen from Hanslow M. Broadvision's statement in which he says,"The original language of Qur'aan was in the Arabic spoken by the Meccan tribe of Quraish and Muhammad belonged to this tribe. The Hebrew language gave rise to two langauges almost simultaneously; one was Aramaic and the other was Arabic. Arabic and Aramaic writings were found ona tablet discovered by French archaeologists in Syria and they have been dated at 500-600 years before the birth of Jesus. It thus shows that the langauge was there far before that date.

From you, Ali Baba: "Can you prove otherwise?  Didn't Osman destroy all the manuscripts?  How can you prove it was written in Arabic?"

He still had some papyrus left up his sleeve. It was written in Koine Greek then translated back into Arabic.      and Dantes said the best,"Human insanity knows no bounds."