Assalamu Alaikum,

I would describe it briefly. There are normally many factors ( more than just one ) when a thread is closed. There is a thread in the Current Events section on this topic, the place where such matters should be started/posted and discussed.

Looking at other aspects, both threads contained good discussions as well as violations . . . I don�t want to go in details here.

Bottom line is that there is a thread on this topic at the right place where discussion can go on and in fact, it goes on.

The original post in this thread indicates that it is addressed to moderator peacemaker. Such threads, regardless of how you interpret it, are complaint threads where a moderator/administrator must take part to clarify the matter; comment threads are where such a participation is not necessitated.

It is imperative that we all comply with guidelines:

Guidelines

peacemaker stop being so pendantic and its not fair on us members and you make it hard participating.

And stop making things as you go along, many reasons you put down is not in the guidelines. It is unfair with your interprations, People know the guideline and yet there is always something you bring along to it that is not in the guidelines, made up. We try to stick to the guidelines the best we can (and yes sometimes things aren't accordingly) but everytime you come and put a reason like the above which is no reason at all (closing it despite a later thread in the supposedly right area is nonsense) but you just being fussing and very particular! And anyway that topic can be anywhere, current events the womans' or about the law, or intrafaith. You are being too head strong with it, guidelines are just that its not some law!

It's gettting very tiring that you move and close threads that do not need to be. And yes some threads could go elsewhere. And another thing I thought decisions were group made amongst the moderators.

Stop with the "there were many violations made" talking naturally is not a machine. Things happen, people need to talk naturally and not feel that something is going be closed or something.

Just stop being so pendantic with it all. that is all you seem to do and rarely get into discussions themselves. Just relax.

I'm sorry but this gets to me everytime and i think its a bit of injustice to the board members.

Just stick to the guidelines and nothing more. Its frustrating with what's happening!

Again sorry for participating in this thread.

When Israfil started his post, Angela's was there, and he saw that.

How did you know that I had seen Angela's post in the first place? Perhaps it is with human error that I overlooked it.

Angel wrote: peacemaker stop being so pendantic and its not fair on us members and you make it hard participating. And stop making things as you go along, many reasons you put down is not in the guidelines. It is unfair with your interprations, People know the guideline and yet there is always something you bring along to it that is not in the guidelines, made up. We try to stick to the guidelines the best we can (and yes sometimes things aren't accordingly) but everytime you come and put a reason like the above which is no reason at all (closing it despite a later thread in the supposedly right area is nonsense) but you just being fussing and very particular! And anyway that topic can be anywhere, current events the womans' or about the law, or intrafaith. You are being too head strong with it, guidelines are just that its not some law! It's gettting very tiring that you move and close threads that do not need to be. And yes some threads could go elsewhere. And another thing I thought decisions were group made amongst the moderators. Stop with the "there were many violations made" talking naturally is not a machine. Things happen, people need to talk naturally and not feel that something is going be closed or something. Just stop being so pendantic with it all. that is all you seem to do and rarely get into discussions themselves. Just relax. I'm sorry but this gets to me everytime and i think its a bit of injustice to the board members. Just stick to the guidelines and nothing more. Its frustrating with what's happening! Again sorry for participating in this thread.

You should not have taken part here in the first place; you did and behaved so rudely. Rules are for everyone. I have interpreted these rules at times, and you ignore them.

Consider this a warning!