I wrote this story about an experience I had from teaching in Iran. I Hope you find it useful:
Brainwashing Backfires
Many years ago, I was a woman teacher in Iran. The following story happened in the early 1990s.
As any teacher or student has experienced, there is always some noise in
the classroom. There is no way to achieve absolute silence, and I don't
believe any attempt should be made to change that. Students need to
talk, and sometimes talking helps them to understand better. I tried to
keep them focused and busy in order to keep them from becoming
distracted. I only interfered in extreme cases, for example when someone
deliberately tried to disturb my class.
During my career, like many teachers, I learned to listen to little
whispers while I pretended that I'm not hearing. That way I could
discover attempts to cheat in exams, conspiracies for avoiding homework
or copying it, etc.
Such whispers were very common and were mostly unimportant. But one day I
heard something that got my attention. Some students were talking about
seeing something which sounded pornographic, or to be more exact, a
rape scene. I knew boys in that age are like that and no matter how much
you try, they will always find ways to get pornographic materials.
Although that disturbed me, I didn’t take it very seriously. I thought
some parents, older brother or … had slipped and left an inappropriate
VHS tape in the video player, or something like that.
But I began to worry when I heard similar whispers in different classes and by different students. That was alarming.
I lived in an Islamic country with a theocratic dictatorial government,
where any relationship between single men and women was banned, even
simple friendship. Sometimes people were arrested, faced with harsh
charges and lashed for small transgressions, for example asking an
address from the opposite sex, etc.
Most of the principals and teachers who were installed in schools were
religious fanatics as well. Many of them were Iran-Iraq war veterans who
the government had employed in order to replace the professional school
staff, which was purged during the 1980s for ideological reasons. They
didn’t know how to treat children. Whenever a student showed a sign of
disobedience, the usual solution was beating him until he started crying
and begging for mercy!
It was surprising to see my students were subjected to inappropriate
sexual material in such a society, despite all the religious lessons
they went through, all the censorship which even banned showing women’s
hair and their singing, harsh rules which restricted the relationships
between opposite sexes, banned cassette and video tapes and players,
etc.
One day I paid a closer attention to a conversation between my students.
They were talking about the same pornographic scene. I deliberately
pretended that couldn't hear and let the conversation to go on. They
were talking about how women were forced by some men to do horrible
humiliating sexual acts, like it’s no big deal. What worried me more was
that they expressed their interest to commit such crimes that men were
committing in that scene. I overheard things like “It’s so much fun”, “I
wish I was there to take part”, “If I was there I would have also
forced those women to do this or that”, “That’s the utter fun you can
have”, etc. At the end of the conversion, I heard one of them say that
he had the tape and was going to give it to his friend after the class.
I waited until the end of the class. When the students began leaving, I
asked the person who I knew had the tape to stay. I waited some more for
everyone aside from him to leave. Then I asked him to hand me his
school bag. Unsurprisingly, the tape was there. When I asked him about
it, he said he had just found it and had no idea what’s on that tape! I
pretended that I believed him and said “Okay. Next time don’t pick up
things that don’t belong to you. I’m keeping this until I find the
owner.”
I took the tape back home to watch it. When the movie began, I was
surprised. It wasn’t pornographic at all. It was a serious movie about a
group of freedom fighters and foreigners who were in Chile during the
1973 coup. I was even interested in the subject, I only couldn’t figure
out what those students found so interesting about this movie. So, I
just sat back to watch it. Who knew? Maybe something inappropriate was
copied in the middle.
The story was good. In one part, a female freedom fighter was identified
and the police were searching for her. Her friend lied to the police
and pretended to be the freedom fighter in order to save her. She was
arrested instead of her and that is when I finally discovered what the
students were talking about. In the movie, female prisoners were taken
to a stadium, where they were sexually harassed in a cruel way.
The film didn’t encourage rape at all. It was the complete the opposite.
The officers who abused the women were the bad guys and a normal viewer
would have felt sympathy for those women. But in my students minds
things were different. They felt no sympathy for the oppressed
prisoners. Their hero was the general who ordered the abuse.
That was saddening to me. If I had just found some ordinary sex scenes,
that was not a big deal, at least for me. Who hasn’t tried to steal a
peak at that age? In that case, I could have mildly reprimanded a
student and asked his parents to keep him off the inappropriate
materials without making a big deal out of what he has done.
But this was different. On one hand, it had become so popular that I
heard the students whispering about it in different times and places. On
the other hand, it wasn’t about ordinary sex between two people, it was
about the desire to reduce people into sex slaves; Something which was
actually condemned in the movie but approved in my student’s minds.
What was wrong with their minds? They were subjected to governmental
propaganda which discouraged that behavior. But despite being bombarded
with that propaganda since they learnt to speak, many of them were
becoming sex predators. This couldn’t have been by chance. There was
something wrong with their education. They were taught lessons which
encouraged a certain religious lifestyle, but what they actually
understood, the outcome of those lessons, was something totally
different.
When we taught them about the Hijab and how women should cover
themselves in order to not stimulate men, what they actually learned was
men are predators and women are preys. Women need to look ugly so they
can avoid being raped by men!
When we taught them how Allah rewards faithful people in Heaven with
Houris (mindless sex machines), what they actually learned was that men
should avoid having healthy and respectful relationships with real women
in this world, in order to achieve those sex machines which are more
attractive than real women, always submissive and stay young forever!
Real women who they see every day are just baits who can deceive men and
deny them such a pleasure!
So, there is not much surprise if a victim of this propaganda, who is
just a human being and has certain needs, can’t wait until death in
order to achieve what he thinks is ideal. He tries to achieve it as much
as possible in his real life. If his ideal is a physically attractive
and submissive woman who has to obey what he commands, then there is no
point in respecting and appreciating the good aspects of women. In such a
mind, a mutually respectful relationship is something earthly and
lowly, not heavenly or ideal. The true pleasure, which is given by
Houris, is awaiting the faithful people in Heaven!
But how could I correct that? I could have told the principle. I was
expected to do that. I once saw the principal severely beating a boy
because he had a music cassette tape with a picture of a foreign singer
on it. So, in this particular case, his interference could have led to
nothing but even worse beating and perhaps humiliating the student who
had the tape in front of the others. The only lesson which the students
could learn this way was how to be more careful and trade their
“contraband” elsewhere.
I decided to give a speech and enlighten the students in my classes. I
told them that I had seen the movie which was circulating in our school
and its story was actually good, despite not being suitable for their
age. I taught them about the political situation in Latin America during
the cold war. After that I explained the movie’s story and told them
about the heroine’s sacrifice for saving her friend. I tried to explain
how cruel the torture was and that no normal person could have fun in
that scenario.
Lastly, but perhaps most important of all, I told them that physical
aspect of sex is something secondary compared to the enjoyment which two
people can have by sharing their best moments together and making each
other happy; That a mature and healthy mind seeks and values the latter
aspect more.
I'm not saying I nullified all of the ideological training which could
turn them into sex predators. But I believe I made a small difference.
The rest was up to the society, families and students themselves.
The lesson that I learned in the process was to judge ideologies and
ideas not by their declared purposes, but by what they actually lead to.
The purpose set for the educational system of Iran was making pious
people out of children, but the process of its work was actually leading
to the opposite. Former generations, who were raised before the
"Islamic Republic" era, were more religious than those who were raised
under the care of religious zealots. Although more religious is by no
means equal to more ethical. As I said, many of the school staff
belonged to that former more religious generation, but their actions
were not ethical at all. Even from a religious point of view, they were
actually undermining their own ideology.
A brainwashing process was taking place, but a brain washed successfully with this method was even dirtier than before!
From my experience during all those years I learned that dictating ideas
and ideologies to students will never work and sometimes it backfires.
The purpose of education should be creating suitable conditions for the
students to do research and figure out things themselves. Even in a
purely scientific field, teachers shouldn't just present facts for their
students to memorize, but should teach them how the scientific research
is done and how proper results can be achieved.