amlhabibi2000 wrote:
Alaikoam Salam
Brothers and Sister thank you for your dialogue!
In the case of a thief or anyone who commits a sin the first priority is to forgive as far as I have understood the sunah as then with forgiveness and educationa, counseling and consultation the person may learn better skills in how to cope with the challenges that caused them to sin in the first place and understand why they sinned also.
|
You do not understand the sunnah very far. As long as certain conditions are met, the hadd (fixed punishment) of a thief is to have the hand cut off. You claim to be a voice of God and you blunder on basic notions in the deen. You cannot even speak with any accuracy for a faith you claim to be a voice for. Pathetic.
Furthermore, Islam is not modeled after some western, juvenile support group model. Thieves are not given counseling, they are punished.
Because the truth is all Mankind is Muslim and if we killed everyone or cut off everyones hand thered be most of mankind dead and most of mankind crippled!
|
1) All of mankind is not Muslim. There are specific requirements to be Muslim. Being part of mankind does not fulfill this requirement. Once more you are spouting off ignorance.
2) The hadd punishement has been carried out for over 1200 years, and there is no rational reason to leave it for the rantings of a self dellusional, self proclaimed religous ignoramus.
3) Since the beginning of these 1200 years, the population of the earth is in no danger of extermination during the use of the hadd. Your conclusions are simply silly.
It says in the Quran to save a life is to save all mankind and therefor our first priority and objective is not to deliberately harm or cause someones death as that is supposed to be up to Allah and His time for our going to the next world is not to be confused with murder.
|
This does not have meaning, at all, when it comes to God's Justice. The use of capital punishment in Islam has never been defined as murder. You are being obtuse.
How can it be a the plan of Allah if someone kills someone intentionally how is that the will of Allah?
|
That would be called murder, and the use of the hadd is not murder. For crying out loud Anne, it is incredible that you feel you have come to bring a message to Muslims and you are clueless about Islam. Try learning what the faith is before you begin to try and change it into something that does not resemble Islam!
Especially when if that same person was educated, counseled and consulted towards better ways of doing things is their ignorance coicidence or just apathy on the part of mankind or themselves?
|
What in the hell are you talking about Anne? Seriously? If someone breaks a crime, the punishement is prescribed, and Allah has commanded that we carry out punishments, regardless of how we feel about them. That is in the Quran. Did God not expect you to read the Quran before He called you to do a mission?
Essentially since we are all Muslim or ie the people in the process of submission or cooperation why is there not in this day and age more education, counseling and consultation services available for free or accessible so everyone may get the skills they need to be good people?
|
Again. What the hell are you talking about? What color is your sky?
Allah guides whom He will to the right path but do we not also have to do a little assisting in this effort?
|
No, we are only to do what we are commanded and to give people the message. It is then up to others to accept the message.
We have to volunteer with community ifra strucutre and support services so they have the people to help the efforts at self development inshallah a great sorting out into groups.
|
What in the name of heaven and earth are you talking about?
Since as I said all life is in a state of Islam we are tested in our daily lives the same as Mohammed PBUH was in the caves and we have a duty to leave a lasting and wonderful legacy just like His PBUH.
Salam
Thank you for your patience!
|
No, Islam is not "life", it is a religion and a way of life that does not need to be reinvented by you. God does not need you, he does not need me, you have a choice to enter into a covenant with God, or not. This covenant requires you to follow a path layed out by God, not an invitation for a self delusional person to try and alter 1200 years of foundation set forth by Allah, His prophet (saw), the first three generations of some of the most piouse men and women who have ever been called Muslim, and piouse savants afterward who worked tirelessly to set forth knowledge to aid us in out path.
Take it or leave it. If you do not like it, then please find another faith to torment with your fringe ideas and nonsense. You have already made declerations that put you outside of Islam, which would make you a kafir.
Edited by Andalus