Shiitism

Brother asda
It seams you are good at history so you must knew there were disagreements  among  most well known companions , some disagreement occurred between two individuals  while some happen among groups . Of cause there were high possibility of other serious sort of conflict between companions were not written down at all .Like you I have read these events but i never try to judge whose opinion is right whose  wrong for I knew I am nothing in front of sahaba . Not only many many things  unknown to us regarding the problems between them  but also it is impossible for us to know Prophet more than companions who saw him & lived with him ,i means we are not  entitled to talk about whose right or wrong since sahaba is better informed than us about Islam   But .... you Asda seams know many many things with certainty Before questioning my love to  Ahlel Bayt (a.s) please question your claim on companions .If you are  not clear on my message ,answer this :

Are you in capability to judge on every disagreement occurred between
companions with certainty?

if you answer is ok,then I will test your knowledge one by one ,you would no longer  need to show your  knowledge . I am going to see if you can be better than sahaba






Edited by Uighur - 24 October 2008 at 5:29am

Br uigher
i hav already proved 2 u dat knoledge is not da criteria of haq.

Wen i read hadith dat "ali(a.s) is wid haq" and that "i hav left u da quran nd ahlel bayt" i dont need 2 think more to judge da ppl who went against da ahlel bayt(a.s).strait away i can say ahlel bayt was haq nd da opposition is not.

Y is it not ez to see black nd white clearly?wen da msg of da prophet (a.s) was clear.

i have simply answered ure above queries... i dont think i can give a more satisfactory answer in proving my position....

Br uigher i hav already proved 2 u dat knoledge is not da criteria of haq. Wen i read hadith dat "ali(a.s) is wid haq" and that "i hav left u da quran nd ahlel bayt" i dont need 2 think more to judge da ppl who went against da ahlel bayt(a.s).strait away i can say ahlel bayt was haq nd da opposition is not. Y is it not ez to see black nd white clearly?wen da msg of da prophet (a.s) was clear.

i dont really care much of the conflicts which did not involve the ahlel bayt (a.s).... as i can only clarify haq and batil when it comes to conflicts where ahlel bayt (a.s) is involved.....

i havent studied much on other disagreements because it was irrelevent to the history of islam....

my judgment is not on my personal likes or dislikes...rather its based on the words of the Prophet (a.s) who cant err....

dere were some conflicts between the sahaaba and the people who were around the Prophet (a.s) which were indirectly linked to the ahlel bayt (a.s)...i am currently studying those...such as the case of H. Abu zarr (r.a) and H.Ammar Yassir (r.a).....and the way they both got killed...